When the Zeros Changed the Conversation
athletic · November 13, 2026
For years, we heard the same concerns about college athletics.
For years, we heard the same concerns about college athletics.
The pressure on student-athletes.
The expectations.
The academic demands.
The physical punishment.
The emotional stress.
The mental health challenges.
Everybody seemed to agree that we needed to do a better job protecting young people from the pressures associated with college sports.
And I agreed.
I still do.
But something interesting happened.
We started adding zeros to the compensation.
Thousands became hundreds of thousands.
Hundreds of thousands became millions.
And suddenly, the conversation about pressure, expectations, mental health, and accountability became considerably more complicated.
So I have a question.
Did the pressure on student-athletes change, or did our willingness to recognize it change when the money arrived?
Remember When They Were Just Kids?
For years, one of the strongest arguments surrounding college athletics was that these were young people trying to balance education and competition.
They were students first.
Athletes second.
At least that was the philosophy we frequently heard.
We were reminded that they experienced anxiety.
Depression.
Burnout.
Academic pressure.
Unrealistic expectations from coaches, fans, parents, and institutions.
And those concerns were legitimate.
The NCAA has spent years developing mental health guidance for its member institutions.
Its updated Mental Health Best Practices became effective August 1, 2024.
Those standards recognize the importance of creating supportive environments, identifying mental health concerns, and providing appropriate resources.
The NCAA's research has also identified academic worries, future planning, finances, and athletic performance as meaningful sources of student-athlete stress.
Those concerns existed before NIL became a major financial opportunity.
And they did not disappear afterward.
[1][2]
Then the Money Entered the Conversation
On July 1, 2021, the NCAA's interim NIL policy took effect.
Student-athletes could begin earning compensation from permitted name, image, and likeness activities without automatically sacrificing NCAA eligibility.
That was a significant change.
And I believe athletes should have the opportunity to benefit financially from their own marketability.
The universities were already generating substantial revenue.
The conferences were making money.
The television networks were making money.
Coaches were receiving enormous contracts.
So the idea that athletes should remain excluded from financial opportunities deserved serious scrutiny.
Then came the House settlement.
Beginning with the 2025-26 academic year, participating Division I institutions were permitted to share revenue directly with athletes.
The College Sports Commission reported approximately $1.77 billion in direct revenue-sharing payments during that first year.
That figure is separate from traditional third-party NIL compensation.
And let us be clear.
Not every college athlete is receiving millions.
Compensation varies enormously by sport, school, marketability, and individual circumstances.
But the financial landscape has fundamentally changed.
[3][4]
Does More Money Mean Less Mental Pressure?
Here is where the contradiction begins.
When athletes were receiving scholarships and relatively limited financial benefits, many people emphasized the emotional consequences of demanding too much from them.
Now an athlete might receive a substantial compensation package.
And suddenly the discussion becomes:
"He is making all that money. He needs to perform."
"She signed the deal. She knew what came with it."
"If they cannot handle the pressure, they should not accept the money."
I understand the business argument.
Compensation creates expectations.
Contracts create obligations.
Organizations investing significant resources expect value.
Fans supporting those organizations have expectations too.
But here is the part that deserves examination.
When did receiving compensation become evidence that someone no longer experiences mental or emotional pressure?
A six-figure agreement does not eliminate anxiety.
A million-dollar arrangement does not guarantee emotional stability.
Financial security may remove certain stressors.
But it can introduce others.
Money May Have Created Additional Pressure
A 2026 peer-reviewed study examined how NIL opportunities affect college-athlete well-being.
Researchers interviewed 14 Division I student-athletes.
They identified potential benefits from NIL but also described pressures involving social media, unequal financial opportunities, personal branding, and the competing responsibilities of being a student, athlete, and influencer.
The study was small and cannot establish how every college athlete experiences NIL.
But it raises an important issue.
What happens when an athlete must perform in the classroom, perform on the field, and perform for sponsors?
The athlete may now have additional responsibilities.
Brand appearances.
Marketing content.
Contractual requirements.
Public engagement.
Financial decisions.
And potentially greater scrutiny from people who believe compensation entitles them to additional access or criticism.
In other words, the money might reduce certain financial pressures while creating new performance-related expectations.
[5]
But Let Us Not Confuse Mental Health With Accountability
Now I want to challenge the other side of this conversation.
Mental health cannot become a universal explanation that automatically removes accountability.
If an athlete enters a legitimate compensation agreement, performance expectations and contractual responsibilities matter.
If a school invests substantial resources in a program, the administration has a responsibility to manage that investment.
If an athlete accepts sponsorship obligations, those commitments deserve attention.
We cannot demand that college athletes be treated as businesspeople when discussing compensation and then insist that business expectations are automatically inappropriate.
That would be inconsistent.
But the opposite position is equally problematic.
We cannot recognize student-athlete mental health when discussing unpaid or undercompensated athletes and then dismiss those concerns once athletes receive substantial compensation.
Accountability and mental health are not mutually exclusive.
An athlete can be responsible for meeting obligations while still needing appropriate mental health support.
A coach can demand excellence without encouraging a harmful environment.
A fan can criticize performance without personally attacking an athlete.
And an institution can protect its financial investment without treating athletes as disposable assets.
Did We Change the Definition of Student-Athlete?
This may be the larger question.
For decades, universities defended college athletics through an educational model.
Scholarships.
Academic development.
Personal growth.
Student welfare.
Athletic participation.
Now many of those same institutions are operating within a system involving direct revenue sharing, substantial NIL agreements, commercial partnerships, and increasingly sophisticated financial negotiations.
That evolution creates tension.
Are we dealing with students who happen to be compensated?
Athletes operating within a commercial enterprise?
Or individuals expected to function as both simultaneously?
Because the answer affects how we discuss everything.
Education.
Compensation.
Performance.
Recruiting.
Mental health.
Contractual expectations.
Institutional accountability.
And even the role of parents when high school athletes enter this marketplace.
We cannot change the business model without reconsidering the responsibilities and protections that accompany it.
The Conversation Should Not Depend on the Dollar Amount
Here is where I stand.
I believe student-athletes should have legitimate opportunities to earn compensation.
I believe institutions should expect accountability when they make financial commitments.
I believe fans have every right to evaluate athletic performance.
I believe schools must continue protecting student-athlete health and well-being.
None of those positions contradict one another.
The problem begins when we selectively apply them.
When someone earns very little, we emphasize compassion.
When someone earns substantially more, we emphasize performance.
When an athlete struggles, we suddenly want to know how much money they received before deciding whether their concerns deserve consideration.
That is a dangerous way to measure someone's humanity.
But ignoring financial responsibility would be equally unreasonable.
The standard should be consistent, even when the compensation is not.
The Zeros Changed the Business. They Should Not Change the Principles.
College athletics has evolved.
The financial opportunities are different.
The expectations are different.
The institutional responsibilities are changing.
But the fundamental question of athlete well-being remains.
How do we develop young people who can compete, learn, earn, and manage the pressures that accompany all three?
That requires more than a mental health awareness campaign.
It requires education.
Financial literacy.
Realistic expectations.
Responsible coaching.
Contractual guidance.
Appropriate professional support.
And the willingness to recognize that compensation does not eliminate human limitations.
The athlete receiving a scholarship deserves consideration.
The athlete receiving $50,000 deserves consideration.
The athlete receiving $1 million deserves consideration.
Their financial circumstances may be different.
Their responsibilities may be different.
Their performance expectations may be different.
But their need for appropriate support does not disappear simply because the paycheck gets bigger.
We spent years telling people that college athletes were experiencing too much pressure.
Then we added zeros to the compensation.
Now the question is whether we still believe what we were saying before the money arrived.
Sources
[1] NCAA. Mental Health Best Practices, Second Edition, effective August 1, 2024.
https://www.ncaa.org/what-we-do/health-safety-and-performance/mental-health/best-practices/
[2] NCAA Research. Student-Athlete Health and Wellness Study.
https://www.ncaa.org/what-we-do/research/studies/student-athlete-health-and-wellness-study/
[3] NCAA. The History of the NCAA, including the 2021 adoption of interim NIL rules.
https://www.ncaa.org/about-us/history/
[4] College Sports Commission. College Sports Commission Tracks $1.8 Billion in Payments to Student-Athletes During First Year of Revenue Sharing, 2026.
https://www.collegesportscommission.org/college-sports-commission-tracks-1-8-billion-in-payments-to-student-athletes-during-first-year-of-revenue-sharing/
[5] Guo, S. X., Chepyator-Thomson, R., Glasgow, S. N., Zhang, J. J., & Zhang, Y. "How Does NIL Policy Impact the Well-Being of College Athletes and Beyond: A Multi-Stakeholder Perspective." INQUIRY, August 29, 2026.
https://doi.org/10.1177/00469580261484287
[6] NCAA. New NCAA Mental Health Best Practices Approved for All Schools to Follow, January 10, 2024.
https://www.ncaa.org/news/mental-health-awareness-month/media-center-new-ncaa-mental-health-best-practices-approved-for-all-schools-to-follow/
Related articles
All articles