Why Are We Paying for Programs in Prison? The Cost Does Not Stop at the Cell.
justice · November 6, 2026
Every now and then, I hear somebody ask a question about the American correctional system.
Every now and then, I hear somebody ask a question about the American correctional system.
"Why are we spending taxpayer money providing programs to people who are in jail or prison?"
Why are they going to school?
Why are they taking college classes?
Why do they have religious services?
Why are we paying for substance-use treatment, vocational training, counseling, and other activities?
And somebody will eventually say:
"They committed a crime. They are supposed to be punished."
I understand the argument.
People have been harmed.
Families have lost loved ones.
Victims have experienced trauma.
Communities have paid the price for criminal behavior.
Taxpayers have legitimate questions about how public money is being spent.
Those concerns should not automatically be dismissed.
But there is another side of this conversation that I believe people should understand before deciding whether correctional programming is a waste of money.
Why were these programs created in the first place?
What are they supposed to accomplish?
What does the research actually show?
And perhaps most importantly:
Who benefits when they work, and who pays when they do not?
Because incarceration affects more than the person sitting inside the cell.
First, Jail and Prison Are Not the Same Thing
Before discussing programs, we need to make an important distinction.
Jails generally operate at the local level. They hold people awaiting trial, sentencing, transfer, or serving relatively short sentences.
Prisons generally hold people convicted of offenses and sentenced to longer periods of incarceration.
That distinction matters because not everybody sitting in an American jail has been convicted of a crime.
According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, 68% of people held in local jails at midyear 2024 were unconvicted. They were awaiting court action or being held for other reasons.
That represents approximately 450,700 people.
So when somebody says:
"They committed a crime. Why are we giving them anything?"
The statement does not accurately describe everybody in custody.
Some are awaiting the outcome of their cases.
Others have been convicted.
And the legal responsibilities of correctional institutions differ depending on those circumstances.
[1]
These Programs Did Not Start Yesterday
Some people talk about prison education and religious programs as though they are relatively new ideas created by modern politicians.
They are not.
The history goes back to the early development of American corrections.
In 1787, reformers in Philadelphia established the Philadelphia Society for Alleviating the Miseries of Public Prisons.
Their goal was to examine the harsh conditions and punishment practices of the time.
By 1790, Pennsylvania had established a penitentiary arrangement at Walnut Street Jail.
Early correctional reform incorporated religious instruction, labor, and efforts to encourage behavioral change.
The philosophy was that incarceration could involve more than physically holding somebody until the sentence ended.
That did not mean the early systems were necessarily humane or effective.
Many relied on extreme isolation, compulsory labor, and practices that later attracted serious criticism.
The point is that Americans were debating punishment versus reform more than 200 years ago.
In 1876, New York opened the Elmira Reformatory, another influential institution associated with the development of rehabilitation-oriented correctional practices.
Education and behavioral reform were becoming more prominent parts of the discussion.
Correctional programming is not a modern invention. It has been part of the American debate about punishment for generations.
[2][3]
Why Do Prisons Provide Education?
This is probably one of the most frequently misunderstood programs.
Somebody might ask:
"Why should a person who committed a crime receive an education when people outside prison struggle to pay for one?"
That is a reasonable question about fairness and public resources.
But look at the operational purpose.
Education can provide literacy.
A high school equivalency credential.
Job skills.
Career preparation.
Reading comprehension.
Financial knowledge.
And the ability to function more independently after release.
The Federal Bureau of Prisons specifically identifies literacy and marketable skills as reasons for providing educational programming.
Federal institutions offer literacy instruction, English-language programs, parenting education, libraries, and vocational opportunities.
In many circumstances, federal prisoners without a high school diploma or GED are required to participate in literacy instruction.
That is not simply recreation.
It is part of the correctional system's attempt to address problems associated with unemployment, limited education, and successful community reintegration.
[4]
Does Prison Education Actually Work?
This is where research matters.
A major 2013 RAND Corporation study, funded through the U.S. Department of Justice, examined correctional education programs.
Researchers found that incarcerated adults participating in correctional education had 43% lower odds of recidivating than those who did not participate, based on the more rigorous studies examined.
The study also associated participation with improved employment outcomes after release.
Researchers estimated that correctional education could save approximately four to five dollars in reincarceration costs for every dollar spent.
Those are meaningful findings.
But we should interpret them correctly.
The 43% figure refers to lower odds, not a guarantee that 43% fewer participants will commit another offense.
The study also does not prove that every educational program produces the same results.
Program quality matters.
Participant selection matters.
Research methods matter.
A later National Institute of Justice review acknowledged that much of the correctional education research had methodological limitations.
So the defensible conclusion is not:
Every prison program works.
It is:
There is meaningful evidence supporting correctional education, but programs still need rigorous evaluation.
[5][6]
Why Are We Paying for College Classes?
This issue has produced considerable political debate.
In 1994, Congress eliminated federal Pell Grant eligibility for incarcerated students in federal and state prisons.
That changed in stages.
The Second Chance Pell initiative began creating limited opportunities in 2015.
Congress restored broader eligibility through legislation enacted in December 2020.
Beginning July 1, 2023, qualifying incarcerated students could again receive Pell Grants through approved prison education programs.
That does not mean every incarcerated person automatically receives free college.
Eligible programs must satisfy federal requirements involving institutional approval, educational quality, credit transferability, and oversight.
Pell Grants support qualifying educational expenses. They are not simply cash handed to incarcerated students for personal spending.
The question taxpayers should ask is whether the programs provide legitimate education and measurable value.
Are students completing credentials?
Are the credits transferable?
Does the training lead toward actual employment opportunities?
Are the qualifications usable after release?
And are taxpayers receiving a meaningful benefit from the investment?
Those are much stronger questions than simply asking why somebody in prison gets to attend school.
[7][8]
What About Religious Services?
Here is another issue people sometimes misunderstand.
Why should somebody convicted of a serious crime have access to religious services?
Because incarceration does not automatically eliminate constitutional protections.
The First Amendment protects religious exercise, although religious practices in correctional institutions can be subject to legitimate security and operational restrictions.
Congress also passed the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act in 2000.
That law provides protections against substantial burdens on religious exercise for people confined in covered institutions, subject to specific legal exceptions.
The Supreme Court upheld the relevant institutionalized-person provisions in Cutter v. Wilkinson in 2005.
This is not simply government deciding that incarcerated people deserve a religious reward.
It involves legal protections that do not disappear automatically upon conviction.
The Federal Bureau of Prisons uses chaplains, contracted religious leaders, and volunteers to facilitate religious observances, counseling, and spiritual guidance.
There is another distinction.
Providing reasonable access to religious exercise is not the same as requiring someone to participate in religion.
Facilities must also consider security, equal treatment, and the rights of people who do not practice a religion.
[9][10]
What About Substance-Use and Mental-Health Treatment?
Some people believe these services should be available outside prison before money is spent offering them inside.
I agree that access outside prison deserves serious attention.
But that does not answer what correctional institutions should do when people already in their custody require treatment.
The Supreme Court established in Estelle v. Gamble that deliberate indifference to serious medical needs can violate the Eighth Amendment.
That does not guarantee every treatment someone requests.
It does establish that incarceration does not allow government to disregard serious medical needs.
And there are public-safety implications.
A 2025 National Institutes of Health-supported study involving seven Massachusetts county jails examined medication treatment for opioid use disorder.
Among the people studied, receiving medication during incarceration was associated with a 52% lower risk of fatal opioid overdose after release, along with reductions in nonfatal overdose and reincarceration.
That is not simply about making incarceration more comfortable.
It is about treatment, survival, and what happens when someone returns to the community.
[11][12]
Most People Are Coming Back Home
This may be the most important point in the entire discussion.
Most people entering American correctional institutions are not going to remain incarcerated for the rest of their lives.
The CDC notes that approximately 600,000 people leave state and federal prisons annually, while millions more move through local jails.
That means the people we incarcerate today may become our neighbors again.
Our coworkers.
Our customers.
Our employees.
The people sitting beside us in traffic.
The people interacting with our families.
Now ask yourself:
What condition do we want them returning in?
Someone who spent five years doing nothing?
Someone who never addressed a substance-use problem?
Someone who cannot read well enough to complete an employment application?
Someone who returns with no realistic employment skills?
Or someone who used part of that time to develop the tools necessary to live differently?
That does not guarantee the person will change.
But refusing to provide an opportunity does not improve the odds either.
[13]
Families Are Serving a Different Kind of Sentence
We also need to discuss the families.
A person goes to prison.
The spouse may lose income.
The children lose daily access to a parent.
The household may lose stability.
Grandparents may become caregivers.
Transportation costs increase.
Family relationships become more difficult.
According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, an estimated 684,500 incarcerated people in state and federal prisons were parents of minor children in 2016.
Those parents reported approximately 1.47 million minor children.
Those children were not sentenced.
Their families were not sentenced.
Yet they experience consequences.
Parenting programs, family services, educational opportunities, and successful reentry planning can be part of limiting further disruption.
They do not repair every relationship.
They do not erase the harm caused by a crime.
But when we evaluate correctional programming, the impact on families should be part of the conversation.
[14]
What About People Who Will Never Be Released?
Now let us address one of the tougher questions.
"Why educate somebody serving life without parole?"
That question deserves a serious answer.
The traditional reentry argument may not apply to someone who will never leave custody.
But not every correctional program exists exclusively for reentry.
Long-term incarceration also involves managing human behavior inside a controlled institution.
Education can provide structured activity.
Treatment can address behavioral and medical needs.
Religious services can support legally protected religious exercise.
Programs may encourage positive behavior, productive routines, mentoring, and personal development.
Those outcomes can matter to employees and other incarcerated people living and working inside the institution.
An incarcerated person may never return to society.
That person still interacts with correctional officers, medical staff, administrators, volunteers, and other incarcerated people.
The institution still has to maintain order.
The government still has legal obligations.
And the person's sentence does not automatically authorize every additional deprivation imaginable.
That does not mean every program is appropriate for every individual.
It means release is not the only possible reason for providing a program.
The Criticisms Are Not All Unreasonable
I think supporters of correctional programming sometimes make a mistake.
They dismiss nearly every objection as ignorance or hostility toward incarcerated people.
Some objections are based on misunderstandings.
Others raise legitimate policy questions.
Consider the concerns.
1. Taxpayer Costs
Programs require money.
Instructors.
Equipment.
Classrooms.
Security.
Transportation.
Technology.
Administrative personnel.
Every dollar spent has an opportunity cost.
The public deserves to know what is being funded and why.
2. Victim and Community Fairness
Victims may still be struggling with medical expenses, trauma, lost wages, or the long-term consequences of crime.
Some reasonably question why correctional programming receives funding while victim services remain inadequate.
That concern should not be ignored.
3. Program Effectiveness
Not every program reduces reoffending.
Not every participant completes training.
Some programs may have weak oversight or offer credentials with limited value.
A program should not be considered successful simply because people attended it.
4. Security and Staffing
Correctional programs require personnel to supervise movement, monitor activities, manage classrooms, and maintain security.
In an understaffed institution, expanding programming without appropriate staffing can create operational difficulties.
5. Unequal Access
Some incarcerated people may receive educational opportunities unavailable to others because of facility placement, security classification, sentence length, funding, or program capacity.
That deserves examination too.
These concerns are legitimate areas for evaluation.
The existence of a potential benefit does not eliminate the need for accountability.
The Benefits Extend Beyond the Incarcerated Person
When programs are properly designed and effective, the benefits can extend beyond the individual participant.
Potential benefits include:
- Improved educational and employment readiness.
- Reduced reoffending and reincarceration.
- Better treatment outcomes.
- Stronger preparation for release.
- Reduced disruption to families.
- Productive activity within institutions.
- Improved behavioral management.
- Reduced future public expenditures.
The Office of Justice Programs has reviewed correctional interventions involving education, employment, cognitive behavioral therapy, substance-use treatment, and reentry services.
The evidence is not equally strong for every type of program.
That is why the objective should be investing in programs with credible evidence and evaluating their performance.
[15]
There Is Another Cost People Forget
The Bureau of Justice Statistics tracked people released from state prisons in 34 states during 2012.
Within five years, approximately 71% had been arrested, while approximately 46% had returned to prison.
Those are different measures.
An arrest is not automatically a conviction.
A return to prison may involve a new sentence or a supervision violation.
And those are historical results for a particular release cohort, not a current national recidivism rate.
But the figures demonstrate the scale of the challenge.
Repeated justice-system involvement has costs.
New investigations.
Court proceedings.
Victimization.
Incarceration.
Community supervision.
Family disruption.
Public expenditures.
So when somebody says:
"Why are we spending money on rehabilitation?"
I would ask another question.
What are we spending when rehabilitation fails?
[16]
Stop Measuring Programs by Their Existence
This is where I would challenge correctional administrators too.
Do not tell the public you have 50 programs and expect applause.
What are they accomplishing?
How many people enrolled?
How many completed?
What did participants learn?
How many received credentials?
How many obtained employment after release?
How many returned to incarceration?
How much did the program cost?
How were victims and communities considered?
Did the program create additional demands on correctional staff?
Could the same outcome have been achieved more effectively through another approach?
A program being offered is not proof that a program is working.
That distinction should drive the entire accountability conversation.
Maybe We Are Asking the Wrong Question
I do not believe every incarcerated person will change.
I do not believe every correctional program works.
I do not believe government should spend money without demonstrating the purpose and effectiveness of that spending.
I also do not believe incarceration should automatically become a period during which government abandons every attempt to address the circumstances associated with criminal behavior.
There is a difference between punishment and purposeless confinement.
There is a difference between accountability and denying somebody the opportunity to improve.
And there is a difference between spending money on a person and investing money to prevent future harm.
The correctional system has multiple responsibilities.
Hold people accountable.
Protect the public.
Maintain security.
Protect employees.
Respect legal obligations.
Provide appropriate treatment.
And, where possible, reduce the likelihood that someone returns to criminal behavior after release.
Those responsibilities do not always fit neatly together.
That is why correctional policy is complicated.
So Why Do We Have Programs in Jail and Prison?
Because American corrections developed around competing purposes that have existed for generations.
Punishment.
Incapacitation.
Deterrence.
Rehabilitation.
Public safety.
And the legal obligations that come with government custody.
Some programs exist because the law requires certain protections.
Some exist because research indicates they can improve outcomes.
Some exist to help maintain institutional order.
Some exist to prepare people for release.
Some exist because government has determined that the public may benefit more from addressing a problem than simply allowing that problem to continue.
That does not make every program worthwhile.
It makes the conversation worth having.
We should be able to question the cost.
We should be able to question the results.
We should be able to question the priorities.
We should also be willing to understand why the programs exist before declaring that they should not.
Because when somebody goes to prison, the consequences do not stop at the cell door.
The victim may still be recovering.
The family may still be struggling.
The correctional officer still has to manage the environment.
The taxpayer is still funding the institution.
And eventually, in most cases, the person who was incarcerated will return to society.
So maybe the better question is not simply why we spend money on people in prison.
Maybe it is whether the money we spend is producing safer institutions, stronger families, fewer victims, and better outcomes for the communities those individuals may eventually return to.
That is the conversation worth having.
Sources
[1] Bureau of Justice Statistics. Jail Inmates in 2024: Statistical Tables, September 2026.
https://bjs.ojp.gov/library/publications/jail-inmates-2024-statistical-tables/web-report
[2] Eastern State Penitentiary Historic Site. History of Eastern State Penitentiary.
https://easternstate.org/about/history-of-eastern-state-penitentiary
[3] New York State Archives. Elmira Correctional Facility: Institutional History.
https://www.archives.nysed.gov/creator-authority/elmira-correctional-facility
[4] Federal Bureau of Prisons. Education Programs.
https://www.bop.gov/inmates/custody_and_care/education.jsp
[5] U.S. Department of Justice / RAND Corporation. Evaluating the Effectiveness of Correctional Education: A Meta-Analysis of Programs That Provide Education to Incarcerated Adults, 2013.
https://www.ojp.gov/library/publications/evaluating-effectiveness-correctional-education-meta-analysis-programs-provide
[6] National Institute of Justice. First Step Act: Best Practices for Academic and Vocational Education for Offenders.
https://nij.ojp.gov/library/publications/first-step-act-best-practices-academic-and-vocational-education-offenders
[7] U.S. Department of Education. Prison Education Programs: Questions and Answers.
https://www.ed.gov/laws-and-policy/higher-education-laws-and-policy/prison-education-programs-questions-and-answers
[8] Federal Student Aid. Prison Education Programs: Best Interest Determination, April 6, 2026.
https://fsapartners.ed.gov/knowledge-center/library/electronic-announcements/2026-04-06/prison-education-programs-best-interest-determination
[9] U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division. Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act.
https://www.justice.gov/crt/religious-land-use-and-institutionalized-persons
[10] Federal Bureau of Prisons. Religious Programs.
https://www.bop.gov/inmates/custody_and_care/religious_programs.jsp
[11] Supreme Court of the United States. Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97 (1976).
https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/429/97/
[12] National Institutes of Health. Treating Opioid Addiction in Jails Improves Treatment Engagement, Reduces Overdose Deaths and Reincarceration, September 10, 2025.
https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/treating-opioid-addiction-jails-improves-treatment-engagement-reduces-overdose-deaths-reincarceration
[13] Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Providing Support for Reentry for Formerly Incarcerated.
https://www.cdc.gov/correctional-health/reentry/index.html
[14] Bureau of Justice Statistics. Parents in Prison and Their Minor Children: Survey of Prison Inmates, 2016.
https://bjs.ojp.gov/library/publications/parents-prison-and-their-minor-children-survey-prison-inmates-2016
[15] Office of Justice Programs. The Use and Impact of Correctional Programming for Inmates on Pre- and Post-Release Outcomes.
https://www.ojp.gov/library/publications/use-and-impact-correctional-programming-inmates-pre-and-post-release-outcomes
[16] Bureau of Justice Statistics. Recidivism of Prisoners Released in 34 States in 2012: A Five-Year Follow-Up Period (2012–2017).
https://bjs.ojp.gov/library/publications/recidivism-prisoners-released-34-states-2012-5-year-follow-period-2012-2017
Key takeaways
- Correctional education, religious services, work programs, and rehabilitative efforts have roots extending back to the early development of American prisons.
- Jails and prisons serve different purposes. Many people in local jails have not been convicted of the charges for which they are being held.
- Some correctional services involve constitutional or statutory protections. Others are programmatic decisions based on rehabilitation, institutional management, or public-policy objectives.
- RAND research found that correctional education participation was associated with 43% lower odds of recidivism in the more rigorous studies examined.
- Pell Grant eligibility for qualifying incarcerated students was restored beginning July 1, 2023, subject to federal prison education program requirements.
- Religious exercise retains legal protection during incarceration, subject to applicable security and operational limitations.
- Treatment programs can have measurable public-health benefits, including reduced overdose risk following release.
- People serving life sentences may still benefit from programming aimed at institutional behavior, health, education, and legally protected activities.
Frequently asked questions
- Are people in prison legally entitled to a college education?
- There is no general federal constitutional right guaranteeing every incarcerated adult a college education. Educational opportunities depend on applicable laws, correctional policies, program availability, and eligibility requirements. Certain federal programs and disability-related protections may create specific obligations.
- Why are religious services available in prison?
- Incarcerated people retain protections for religious exercise under the First Amendment and applicable federal law, including RLUIPA. Those protections are not unlimited and must be balanced against legitimate institutional security requirements.
- Do taxpayers pay for prison college programs?
- Some programs receive federal Pell Grant funding, state appropriations, institutional funding, philanthropic support, or other resources. The specific funding arrangement depends on the program. Federal Pell funding is restricted to qualifying students enrolled in approved programs.
- Why provide programs to people serving life sentences?
- Programs can serve purposes beyond preparation for release, including health care, institutional behavior, productive activity, personal development, religious exercise, and safer correctional operations.
- Do rehabilitation programs guarantee someone will not commit another crime?
- No. Research supports benefits from certain educational, treatment, and behavioral interventions, but outcomes vary. No program can guarantee that a participant will never reoffend.
- Should victim services receive equal attention?
- Yes. The effects of crime on victims and their families are central to criminal justice policy. Investments in rehabilitation should be evaluated alongside victim assistance, public safety, and other community needs. ---
Related articles
All articles