Any Position Come for Me?
justice · November 16, 2026
There is something about The Color Purple that stays with you.
When working titles multiply, but field staffing still matters.
There is something about The Color Purple that stays with you.
The anticipation.
The waiting.
The hope that something important might finally arrive.
And for some reason, that familiar scene came to mind when I started thinking about certain staffing practices I observed during my years with Maryland's Division of Parole and Probation.
Except this time, nobody is waiting for a letter.
Somebody might be waiting for a position.
"Any position come for me?"
Now, I can laugh at that.
But behind the humor is a serious organizational question.
Is the Division of Parole and Probation creating meaningful operational capacity, or simply moving experienced employees around while giving the movement new titles?
There is a difference.
And it deserves examination.
When Everybody Gets a Title, Who Is Left to Do the Work?
Throughout my career with the Division of Parole and Probation, I observed personnel assignments and working titles that sometimes left me questioning how particular staffing decisions were made.
Let me be clear.
I am not suggesting every specialized assignment is unnecessary.
I am not suggesting management lacks the authority to assign employees to different responsibilities.
Organizations evolve.
Responsibilities change.
Specialized expertise becomes necessary.
Professional development matters.
I understand all of that.
But here is what I want people to consider.
An experienced employee is working in a field office.
That employee is selected for a specialized assignment.
The new assignment may come with a coordinator title, liaison responsibility, special project designation, or another working title.
Those are illustrative examples, not allegations about specific positions.
Now the original field assignment needs coverage.
So another employee may be reassigned.
Or the remaining employees absorb additional responsibilities.
Or management must recruit and train a replacement.
One organizational decision can create several additional staffing demands.
And after all that movement, we still need to ask:
Did the organization gain capacity, or did it simply relocate the capacity it already had?
Because moving experience from one place to another does not automatically create more experience.
A new working title does not automatically create a new employee.
And a new assignment does not eliminate the work somebody left behind.
The workload does not disappear because the nameplate changed.
Maryland Actually Encourages Working Titles
Here is where the conversation becomes interesting.
Maryland's Department of Budget and Management recognizes the distinction between an employee's official classification and the working title used to describe the position.
The state's MS-22 Position Description instructions specifically allow a working title that differs from the official classification title.
So working titles are not inherently improper.
They are part of Maryland's personnel management system.
The issue becomes even more interesting when examining the October 31, 2023, presentation to the Task Force on the Modernization of the State Personnel Management System.
The presentation included a section titled:
"Shift Away From Classification Titles to Working Titles."
DBM explained that agencies were increasingly identifying both official classification titles and working or business titles.
According to the presentation, the practice helped classification personnel identify comparable positions and process reclassification requests more efficiently.
DBM also discussed using working titles to make recruitment advertisements more understandable to job applicants.
The presentation offered an example involving an HR Analyst Senior position advertised as a Salary Analyst because that working title better described the work.
That makes sense.
A clear working title can help someone understand a position without having to decipher a complicated government classification.
But let us not confuse the purpose of a working title with the operational justification for an assignment.
A working title explains what somebody does. It does not automatically explain why the organization needs a separate person doing it.
Those are different questions.
[1][2]
What Does the Position Actually Accomplish?
Suppose management identifies the need for a specialized coordinator.
Fine.
What problem is that coordinator supposed to solve?
Is the work new?
Was someone already performing those duties?
Does the assignment require a dedicated employee?
Could those responsibilities reasonably fit within an existing organizational structure?
Does the position require expertise that cannot be provided another way?
How will management determine whether the assignment is successful?
And my favorite question:
What happened to the responsibilities the employee left behind?
That last question should not be an afterthought.
It should be part of the decision before the reassignment occurs.
Because every organization has limited resources.
And in an agency responsible for community supervision and public safety, staffing decisions carry operational consequences.
The Field Cannot Keep Absorbing Every Decision
The Division of Parole and Probation is not an organization where experience can always be replaced immediately.
Community supervision requires knowledge of court orders, case management, supervision strategies, risk assessment, investigations, documentation, and public safety responsibilities.
Experienced agents and supervisors develop judgment that comes from performing the work.
That experience has value.
When an experienced employee leaves a field assignment, the impact may extend beyond a vacant position.
Other employees may inherit additional responsibilities.
Supervisors may have to restructure workloads.
New employees may need considerable training.
Existing employees may be expected to compensate for the transition.
And depending on the circumstances, the organization may lose operational efficiency while attempting to create it elsewhere.
That does not mean specialized assignments should never occur.
It means leadership should account for the consequences.
A staffing decision that strengthens one office while weakening another deserves more than a new organizational chart.
The Vacancy Numbers Make This Conversation Relevant
Maryland's fiscal 2027 budget analysis provides important context.
According to the Department of Legislative Services, DPSCS Community Supervision initially reported 92 vacant positions as of December 31, 2025.
The analysis subsequently noted that Community Supervision identified 97 vacancies for that same period.
Community Supervision includes the Division of Parole and Probation and the Maryland Parole Commission.
These figures do not establish how many vacancies were field positions, how many resulted from internal reassignments, or whether any particular working title contributed to staffing shortages.
I am not suggesting otherwise.
But they establish something important.
The organization was operating with documented vacancies.
The same budget analysis identified a fiscal 2027 Community Supervision allowance of approximately $145.5 million, with roughly 90% allocated to personnel expenses.
When personnel account for such a substantial portion of the budget, decisions about how those personnel are assigned deserve serious attention.
It is not enough to know how many positions exist.
We should also know where the employees are working, what responsibilities they perform, and whether those assignments support the agency's operational needs.
An authorized position on paper is not the same as an experienced employee available to perform field duties.
[3]
A Position Identification Number Is Not a Performance Measure
Maryland uses official classifications, position identification numbers, position descriptions, and established personnel procedures.
Those processes matter.
State Personnel and Pensions § 4-203 establishes requirements governing classification titles and classification oversight.
Section 7-602 addresses employee reassignments and transfers, including qualifications, grade and service requirements, and notice provisions.
Management has legitimate authority to make personnel decisions within applicable legal and administrative requirements.
But something can be procedurally permissible without necessarily being the most effective operational decision.
A reassignment may comply with personnel rules while creating an additional burden on a field office.
A working title may accurately describe an employee's assigned duties without demonstrating that a dedicated assignment was the best use of available staffing.
A position may have a legitimate identification number without proving that its existence improves organizational performance.
Compliance establishes whether management followed applicable rules. Effectiveness establishes whether the decision produced the intended results.
Leadership should care about both.
[4][5]
Opportunity and Organizational Necessity Are Not the Same Thing
I support professional development.
I support employees gaining new experiences.
I support leadership development and opportunities for advancement.
Those opportunities can benefit employees and strengthen organizations.
But here is the distinction.
An opportunity for an employee is not automatically an operational necessity for the organization.
Sometimes the two align perfectly.
An employee advances into a specialized assignment.
The agency gains valuable expertise.
A documented problem gets resolved.
Field operations remain adequately staffed.
Everybody benefits.
That is good management.
But sometimes an assignment may create additional staffing demands without a clearly demonstrated organizational benefit.
That possibility deserves scrutiny.
And the people accepting those assignments should not automatically become the targets of criticism.
Employees generally do not establish the organizational structure or approve every staffing decision.
The responsibility for explaining those decisions belongs with management.
Seven Questions Leadership Should Be Able to Answer
Rather than assuming an assignment is unnecessary, I would prefer that DPP leadership be able to answer seven straightforward questions.
- What operational need prompted the assignment? What problem was management attempting to solve?
- What official classification and position identification number support it? Is the assignment associated with an established position, a reclassification, or an existing employee's revised duties?
- What responsibilities distinguish the assignment from existing positions? Are the duties genuinely different, or do they overlap substantially with work already being performed?
- How was the employee selected? What qualifications were required, and what applicable personnel procedures governed the decision?
- What happened to the employee's previous responsibilities? Were they reassigned, absorbed, eliminated, or left temporarily uncovered?
- What was the operational cost of the decision? Did it create staffing shortages, increase workloads, require replacement training, or reduce field experience?
- What measurable results justify continuing the assignment? What improved because the organization made this decision?
Those answers might demonstrate that every questioned assignment was entirely appropriate.
They might also reveal opportunities to improve staffing practices.
Either outcome would be useful.
Transparency should not be treated as an attack on leadership. It should be considered part of responsible leadership.
The Organizational Chart Can Look Better Than the Organization Operates
Here is something I learned through years of supervising employees and observing government operations.
An organizational chart can be impressive.
Boxes.
Lines.
Titles.
Coordinators.
Specialists.
Program managers.
Liaisons.
But the chart does not perform the work.
People do.
And every additional assignment should be evaluated in relation to the organization's mission.
Are field operations stronger?
Are workloads manageable?
Are supervisors receiving meaningful support?
Are services being delivered more effectively?
Are employees adequately prepared and equipped?
Are operational problems being resolved?
Does the assignment reduce unnecessary work or simply redistribute it?
Those are the measurements that matter.
Because an organization can look well structured while the employees responsible for delivering its services remain stretched.
More titles do not necessarily mean more capacity.
And more assignments do not necessarily mean better management.
Any Position Come for Me?
I return to that familiar image from The Color Purple.
Someone waiting.
Someone hoping.
Someone wondering whether something has finally arrived.
Only this time, I imagine the question coming from somewhere inside a government office.
"Any position come for me?"
Maybe there is a new coordinator assignment.
Maybe there is a special project.
Maybe there is another working title.
Maybe the assignment is necessary.
Maybe it is an excellent opportunity for a deserving employee.
I am not dismissing those possibilities.
My concern has never been that employees should not have opportunities to advance.
My concern is whether organizational opportunities are being created and managed in ways that strengthen the entire operation.
Because DPP has responsibilities that extend far beyond any individual assignment.
The courts expect supervision.
The public expects safety.
Employees deserve reasonable workloads and appropriate support.
The people under supervision require consistent services and accountability.
And leadership has a responsibility to make staffing decisions that support those obligations.
When an experienced field employee moves into another assignment, leadership should be able to demonstrate the value of that decision while accounting for the impact on the position left behind.
Not simply explain the title.
Not simply identify the employee selected.
Not simply point to an authorized position.
Explain what improved.
Because the value of a position should not be measured by how important its title sounds, but by whether the work justifies the organizational resources devoted to it.
I am not alleging that every specialized assignment is unnecessary.
I am not alleging that a particular employee or official violated Maryland personnel law.
I am asking whether the Division of Parole and Probation can consistently demonstrate that its personnel decisions strengthen its ability to accomplish its mission.
That should not be an unreasonable expectation.
And until that conversation takes place, perhaps the question remains:
"Any position come for me?"
But I have a better one.
"Any accountability come with it?"
Sources and References
[1] Maryland Department of Budget and Management. Instructions for Completing Position Description Form MS-22.
https://dbm.maryland.gov/employees/pages/pep/ms22instructions.aspx
[2] Maryland Department of Budget and Management. Task Force on the Modernization of the State Personnel Management System, October 31, 2023. Presentation materials, including "Shift Away From Classification Titles to Working Titles."
https://dbm.maryland.gov/employees/Documents/SPMS-TaskForce/SPMS%20Task%20Force%20Presentation%20Materials%2010.31.23.pdf
[3] Maryland Department of Legislative Services. Analysis of the FY 2027 Maryland Executive Budget, DPSCS Community Supervision (Q00C), 2026.
https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/pubs/budgetfiscal/2027fy-budget-docs-operating-Q00C-DPSCS-Community-Supervision.pdf
[4] Maryland General Assembly. State Personnel and Pensions § 4-203, Classification Plans and Titles.
https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/mgawebsite/laws/StatuteText?article=gsp§ion=4-203
[5] Maryland General Assembly. State Personnel and Pensions § 7-602, Reassignments and Transfers.
https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/mgawebsite/laws/StatuteText?article=gsp§ion=7-602
Author's Note: This commentary reflects personal observations and examines questions of organizational effectiveness, personnel allocation, and public-sector accountability. It does not allege that a particular employee, assignment, or agency official violated Maryland personnel law or policy. Determining the justification and operational impact of specific assignments would require review of relevant personnel records, position descriptions, staffing data, and organizational decisions.
Key takeaways
- Maryland formally recognizes working titles that differ from official personnel classifications.
- DBM has discussed increased use of working titles to clarify responsibilities and improve recruitment.
- The legitimate use of a working title does not automatically establish that a separate assignment represents the best allocation of personnel.
- The fiscal 2027 budget analysis documented 92 initially reported Community Supervision vacancies for December 2025, later revised to 97.
- Those vacancy figures do not establish that internal reassignments caused staffing shortages.
- Employee development opportunities and organizational necessity can overlap, but they are not interchangeable.
- Leadership should evaluate both the benefit of specialized assignments and their impact on field staffing.
- The appropriate accountability measure is whether personnel decisions improve operational performance.
Related articles
All articles