The Rule Was There All Season. Why Did the Forfeit Come at Playoff Time?
commentary · November 1, 2026
Imagine playing an entire high school football season.
Imagine playing an entire high school football season.
Summer workouts.
August practices.
Friday night games.
Wins.
Community support.
Championship expectations.
Your team reaches the final week undefeated on the field.
Then, just as playoff positioning is being determined, an administrative violation changes the official record.
That brings me to the recent situation involving Dr. Henry A. Wise Jr. High School in Prince George's County, Maryland.
And I have a question.
Why are we still discovering problems this late in the season?
The Wise Situation Deserves Attention
Wise entered the final week of the 2026 regular season among Maryland's undefeated Class 4A football programs.
On October 31, The MoCo Show reported that MPSSAA playoff point standings had been adjusted to reflect officially reported violations and forfeitures affecting several programs, including Wise.
The available reporting does not fully establish the specific violation involving Wise, when officials first became aware of it, or the complete postseason consequences.
Those details matter.
I am not going to accuse a student, coach, athletic director, or school administrator of wrongdoing without that information.
But the timing raises an important administrative question.
How does a team reach the end of the regular season before a compliance issue affects its official record?
I Am Not Arguing Against the Rule
Maryland regulations are clear.
Under COMAR 13A.06.03.05, a school violating MPSSAA regulations can be required to forfeit games in which the violation occurred.
The rules also establish procedures for investigation, penalties, and appeals.
That is not something governing bodies should simply ignore because a team is undefeated or approaching the playoffs.
Fairness matters.
Eligibility matters.
Competitive integrity matters.
But enforcement and prevention are different responsibilities.
A valid penalty does not automatically mean the system worked properly.
What Was Happening During the Season?
This is what bothers me.
Schools already maintain enrollment information.
Residency records.
Transfer documentation.
Academic eligibility.
Student participation records.
Official rosters.
There are administrators responsible for reviewing eligibility.
So what happens after the initial certification?
Is eligibility checked again?
Are transfer documents reviewed throughout the season?
Does somebody reconcile the roster against actual participation?
Are unresolved eligibility questions tracked?
Are schools notified promptly when concerns arise?
Those questions are not accusations.
They are questions about the process.
We Have Seen Similar Consequences Before
Maryland experienced major late-season eligibility forfeitures in 2025.
North Point lost seven victories because of a residency eligibility violation.
C.H. Flowers also forfeited victories after an eligibility determination.
Those decisions affected team records and playoff positioning.
Now Wise appears among the schools affected by official adjustments as the 2026 postseason approaches.
The individual circumstances may differ.
But the larger question remains.
Why does the system sometimes reach the punishment stage so late?
The Student-Athletes Bear the Consequences
Consider the senior who followed every rule.
Attended practice.
Maintained academic eligibility.
Played every game.
Helped the team win.
Now that athlete may watch the team's official record or postseason positioning change because of an administrative issue.
Perhaps the violation was unavoidable.
Perhaps someone withheld information.
Perhaps a procedural mistake occurred.
We should establish those facts before assigning responsibility.
But one thing is certain.
The consequences can extend beyond whoever committed the violation.
That should make prevention a priority.
Build Checkpoints Before Playoff Time
I would like to see schools establish five documented checkpoints:
- Preseason certification: Verify every athlete before participation.
- Early-season reconciliation: Match game participation records against approved eligibility rosters.
- Midseason review: Recheck transfers, residency changes, academics, and unresolved concerns.
- Pre-playoff audit: Complete an expedited compliance review before final seeding.
- Post-violation review: Determine why the problem was not identified sooner and what must change.
These safeguards would supplement existing requirements, not replace them.
They would not catch everything.
But they could identify preventable problems earlier.
The Bigger Accountability Question
The MPSSAA should enforce its rules.
Schools should follow them.
Athletes and families should provide accurate information.
But accountability should also include the process responsible for identifying violations.
When did the issue first exist?
When was it reported?
When was it investigated?
Could it have been detected sooner?
Was anyone aware of a problem before the final weeks?
What improvements will follow?
Those answers matter just as much as the final penalty.
Because this is high school athletics.
Education is supposed to be part of the experience.
We should be teaching accountability, responsibility, and prevention.
Not simply discovering problems when the season is nearly over.
The Wise situation deserves a clear explanation.
Not because Wise should receive special treatment.
Because every high school athlete deserves a system that works before the consequences become irreversible.
The rule was there in August.
The responsibility existed in September.
The season continued through October.
So when playoff time arrives, I want to know more than who must forfeit.
I want to know why the problem was not resolved earlier, and what will prevent it from happening again.
Sources
The MoCo Show, "Maryland High School Football Playoff Picture Takes Shape as Regular Season Ends," October 31, 2026.
https://mocoshow.com/2026/10/31/maryland-high-school-football-playoff-picture-takes-shape-as-regular-season-ends/
Maryland Regulations, COMAR 13A.06.03.05, Violations, Penalties, and Appeals.
https://regs.maryland.gov/us/md/exec/comar/13A.06.03.05
MPSSAA, Football State Championships and 2026 Calendar.
https://www.mpssaa.org/sports/football/
The Washington Post, "Forfeits by North Point, C.H. Flowers headline Week 10 HS football Top 20," November 3, 2025.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2025/11/03/high-school-football-top-20-10/
Related articles
All articles